Meiomi vs La Crema: which Pinot Noir should you buy?
🦙 Paco's verdict: La Crema by a nose
La Crema is the pick if you want a Pinot that tastes a little more like Pinot — drier, brighter, more honest. Meiomi wins if you want it soft, dark, and faintly sweet, the bottle that pleases a whole table. Neither is a trophy; both are reliable crowd-pleasers in the same neighborhood.
Quick answer
Both land around ~$20-$25 and both are made to be liked. La Crema runs drier and more structured, so it reads as the more serious, food-friendly Pinot. Meiomi is the plush, slightly sweet, coffee-and-mocha crowd bottle. If you're choosing blind for yourself, go La Crema; if you're feeding a mixed crowd that "doesn't like dry reds," go Meiomi.
Best Overall
La Crema, narrowly. It tastes more like actual Pinot Noir — red fruit, a little earth, real acidity — without going austere. Meiomi is delicious in a different way, but that softness comes from a riper, sweeter, more polished profile that can feel engineered. If you want one bottle that does the most Pinot things right, La Crema is the safer call. Exception: if everyone at your table flinches at the word "dry," Meiomi is the better overall pick for that room. Best overall depends on who's drinking.
Best Value
Call it a tie, leaning Meiomi. They sit in the same ~$20-$25 band, and at that price both overdeliver on consistency — you basically know what you're getting every time. Meiomi gets the slight nod because its richer, sweeter style tastes "more expensive" to most casual drinkers, so it punches above its price at a party. If you actually like Pinot, La Crema is the better value for the dollar because you're paying for structure, not sweetness.
Best for dinner
La Crema, clearly. The extra acidity and drier finish make it a real food wine — it cuts through salmon, roast chicken, mushroom pasta, pork, even a holiday turkey. Meiomi's sweetness and plush body can fight savory food and start to feel heavy by the second glass. Exception: if dinner is something smoky, saucy, or barbecue-leaning, Meiomi's mocha richness can actually be the better match.
Best for gifting
Meiomi. The dark, heavy bottle and instantly recognizable label look like you spent more, and the crowd-pleasing taste means almost no one will be disappointed. It's a confident hand-it-over gift for someone whose palate you don't know. La Crema gifts well too, especially for someone who actually drinks Pinot — it just reads a touch more low-key on the shelf.
Style difference
This is the whole decision. Meiomi is soft, dark, full-bodied, and faintly sweet, with coffee, mocha, and jammy black fruit — Pinot dialed toward dessert-adjacent comfort. La Crema is lighter on its feet, drier, with brighter red fruit and more acidity — Pinot dialed toward the table. Short version: Meiomi is the smoothie, La Crema is the wine. Both are well-made; they're just aiming at different drinkers.
If it were my money
I'd buy La Crema for myself and most dinners — I want a Pinot that tastes like Pinot, and the drier honesty wins over time. I'd grab Meiomi when I'm pouring for a crowd that wants something soft and approachable, or when I need a gift bottle that looks the part. Neither is a bottle to chase or cellar. Buy whichever style you actually want that night, and don't pay more than the ~$20-$25 they normally run.
Want Paco to check your bottle or wine list?
Send Paco a bottle photo, wine list, or shop screenshot and get the call in seconds:
- 🍷 what to buy
- 💰 what's worth it
- 🚫 what to skip
Bottom line
La Crema for a touch more honesty and food-friendliness; Meiomi if you want it softer, sweeter, and crowd-proof. Same price neighborhood, two different missions — pick the style, not the label, and don't overpay past ~$20-$25.
Frequently asked questions
- Is Meiomi sweeter than La Crema?
- Yes. Meiomi is noticeably softer and faintly sweet, with coffee and mocha richness, while La Crema runs drier with brighter acidity. If "too sweet for a red" is a worry, go La Crema.
- Which one is better with food?
- La Crema. Its higher acidity and drier finish make it more versatile at the table — salmon, chicken, pork, mushrooms, turkey. Meiomi can feel heavy against savory dishes but shines with smoky or barbecue food.
- Are Meiomi and La Crema the same price?
- Roughly, yes — both typically land around ~$20-$25. Value comes down to style: Meiomi tastes "richer" for the money to casual drinkers, La Crema gives you more real Pinot structure per dollar.
- What would Paco buy?
- La Crema for myself and most dinners, because I want a Pinot that tastes like Pinot. Meiomi when I'm pouring for a crowd that wants soft and easy, or when I need a gift bottle that looks the part. Just don't pay above the ~$20-$25 they usually run.
Still deciding?
Ask Paco before you buy, open, or order the bottle. Your first 3 wine conversations are free.